Thanks Bill. Yes, you're right it does look like they used Lilith on the poster. A search on Myfonts turns up a digital version called "Annabelle Matinee NF", though it looks like some of the serifs and letter shapes have been changed slightly. On the title page for The Outsider 4/5, it looks like there was an 'engraved' version of the font as well.
On the titling, yes, I checked identifont and left a copy of the scan from hank solo on Myfont's 'WhatTheFont' forum to see if anybody recognized it.