mjp
Founding member
I think it affects you because you are already a fan of her music (and because it's raw and emotional which makes most people uneasy because they are dead inside). I love it, it makes me laugh, and it's nothing at all like anything else you could pick at random from any of her other records.
But I would never play that clip for someone who wasn't already familiar with her. Those I've shown it to who are partial to her music all think it's funny and awesome. You'd have to be pretty humorless not to laugh at someone barking in a song. But if you take it out of the context of her other 150 or so recorded songs, sure it's just noise. Like free jazz, or scat singing.
Her first album, Dry is one of the best straight ahead, loud, great-song rock albums you'll ever hear in your life. All of you, however old you are. But there's a lot more to her than that. Like she can bark, dude! Let's see some uptight jazz bitch do that. They wouldn't have the nerve. They'd be afraid of what the horn player might say. Afraid it wasn't cooooool.
But I would never play that clip for someone who wasn't already familiar with her. Those I've shown it to who are partial to her music all think it's funny and awesome. You'd have to be pretty humorless not to laugh at someone barking in a song. But if you take it out of the context of her other 150 or so recorded songs, sure it's just noise. Like free jazz, or scat singing.
Her first album, Dry is one of the best straight ahead, loud, great-song rock albums you'll ever hear in your life. All of you, however old you are. But there's a lot more to her than that. Like she can bark, dude! Let's see some uptight jazz bitch do that. They wouldn't have the nerve. They'd be afraid of what the horn player might say. Afraid it wasn't cooooool.